In music conservatories around the world, there is a field called Ethnomusicology, which studies how people from different cultures perceive and express their music. However, here lies the problem: if you are a Western scholar, studying the folk music of European countries is manageable. Regardless of whether it's Germany, France, Italy, or Poland, the core elements—the ecclesiastical system, tonal system, and 12-tone equal temperament—are largely shared. They are essentially just different 'accents' of the same piano-based language. Even Indian music, known for its complexity with Ragas, Talas, and microtones, is primarily anchored in two systems: North Indian and South Indian. Consequently, many Western scholars find these systems analytical.
But when they encounter Chinese music, they break down. The differences between our folk music traditions aren't just accents; they are fundamental differences in worldview. Some emphasize pitch, others resonance, space, or ritualistic significance. Some rhythms feel like mathematics, others like temporal philosophy, and some music isn't even meant for human ears but for communion with deities—like Tibetan music. Because our country packs dozens of independent, civilization-level music systems from 56 ethnic groups into one nation, many of these traditions don't just differ in style; they differ in underlying logic.
For example, Mongolian Long Song uses breath, overtones, and sliding pitches to create a sense of spatial infinity, bordering on acoustic art. Just as you master that, you encounter the Dong people's polyphonic singing—a shock to Western ears because it developed naturally without any influence from Western harmony, proving that humanity doesn't need Western music theory to create complex polyphony. Moving west to Xinjiang, the music shifts to Central Asian rhythms and complex melodic loops akin to the Persian and Arabic Maqam system, which could take a lifetime to study. Then, just when you think you've grasped it, Fujian Nanyin arrives—a living fossil of Tang and Song dynasty music. The sheer variety inside China makes it feel like studying a musical version of 'Classic of Mountains and Seas' (Shan Hai Jing). Eventually, the field of ethnomusicology realized a profound truth: Western music theory might just be one special case in the spectrum of human music, rather than a universal truth. From Shaanbei Xintianyou to Miao and Zhuang folk songs, these traditions feel like they evolved from entirely different civilizations.
No comments yet